How antique values are built
Background for every guide on the blog: how a value is put together, which number you are looking at, and when you need a person who signs their name to it.
How a value gets built, line by line
Appraisers work through the same four lines whether the piece is a teacup or a tall case clock. Skip one and the number on the tag means very little.
- 01
Identify it
What it is, who made it and when. Backstamps, hallmarks, signatures, joinery and tool marks narrow the period long before anyone talks price.
- 02
Grade the condition
Chips, cracks, repairs, replaced hardware and refinishing. On many pieces condition moves the price more than age does.
- 03
Find comparables
What similar pieces are listed for now, and what they actually sold for. Asking prices often run above what buyers end up paying, so sold results are the reality check.
- 04
Name the purpose
Selling, insuring, splitting an estate or donating each calls for a different kind of value, and some of them legally require a signed appraisal.
Four numbers people mix up
A price you saw online and a value an appraiser signs are different things. Knowing which one you are looking at saves bad decisions.
What sellers hope for
The price on an active listing. Useful to see the market, but nobody has paid it yet.
What buyers paid
Completed sales and auction results. The strongest evidence for fair market value.
A signed opinion
Written by a qualified appraiser for a stated purpose. Insurance replacement value is usually higher than fair market value.
A listing range
A range from comparable secondhand listings, with how many listings it rests on. A starting point, not an appraisal.
When a photo is not enough
An app is fast and good for sorting a box of finds. Some situations need a person who signs their name to the number.
Get a certified appraisal for
- Insurance scheduling of jewelry, art or silver.
- Dividing an estate or settling probate.
- Charitable donations: the IRS asks for a qualified appraisal for most noncash gifts claimed above $5,000 (IRS Publication 561).
- Pieces you suspect are rare, signed or by a known maker, and any question of authenticity.
Where to find one
- American Society of Appraisers
- International Society of Appraisers
- Appraisers Association of America
Ask whether the report follows USPAP and how the fee is set. Reputable appraisers charge by the hour or a flat fee, not a percentage of the value.